Just a year ago we saw snow storms and long cold spells in Texas that left the state with rolling blackouts that left many in dangerous conditions. Reaching record setting temperatures as low as -2° F, natural gas in Texas literally froze in the pipes which contributed to the blackouts and other problems, such as people losing the ability to cook and heat their homes. Because it's such an important issue, we’ve decided to cover how weather affects fuels and what energy systems are best to keep on hand for extreme weather conditions. We’ll talk about natural gas, propane, and gasoline and weigh just how well each fairs in extreme temperatures.
Although Texas is a special case as it belongs to its own power grid and hasn’t put in place the insulation that those in the midwest and rest of the country use, natural gas is still the most risky when it comes to the cold. Because of methane hydrates in natural gas, the freezing point is actually the same as water at 32° F. Methane, the primary component of natural gas, is a hydrate which means that each molecule carries very small particles of water. When natural gas is processed, there is extreme care in removing as much humidity as possible from the substance to reduce rusting and improve consistency. However, methane cannot be perfectly dried enough to counteract its relatively high freezing point. So, the colder the area is, the more natural gas lines need to be insulated and regulated to maintain its usefulness.
Propane, on the other hand, could easily operate under these same temperatures without freezing. With a freezing point of -188° F, liquid propane will not freeze unless encountering the harshest of temperatures. However, freezing isn’t the only issue when it comes to LPG. The main temperature factor to consider with propane is that it is stored as a liquid but is utilized as a gas as well as the fact that you need pressure to get it from the tank to whatever you are fueling. Because of this, the temperature and pressure needs to be high enough for this state change to occur or else you may get liquid propane coming through your line which is more concentrated and can thus create a hazardous amount of fuel, or your system may fail to work all together because of low pressure. Under about -44° F is when propane begins to shrink which can lower the pressure of your propane tank and prevent it from expelling fuel. Although this temperature is rare in the US, it is not unheard of. Northern states like Michigan and Oregon have both seen record lows exceeding -50° F. There are common practices for preventing such outcomes though such as keeping your tank filled, putting it close to your house, and making sure it has access to sunlight by clearing off snow and making sure it is in a nice sunny spot. It is also recommended to limit fuel use in these conditions. Doing so allows the tank to maintain pressure in between uses.
Finally, we have gasoline, the fuel many in Texas have turned to by using the heaters in their cars after their home systems have failed. Gasoline is actually a mixture of hydrocarbons that have a variety of freezing points ranging from -40° F to as low as -200° F. The general consensus though is that gasoline becomes mostly frozen around -100° F which would be extreme for anywhere in the US. This makes it quite reliable and preferential to natural gas in extreme conditions and slightly easier to use than propane when temperatures exceed -44° F. Something to keep in mind is octane which has a higher freezing point than other components in gasoline. This means that higher octane fuels can actually make your fuel more easily subjected to the cold, although it will not be noticeable under most conditions. It's also important to note that gasoline can separate out its mixture and lower its viscosity at colder temperatures which can be hard on engines and fuel pumps. This can also trick your fuel meter into thinking you have more fuel than you actually do. Gasoline has its own set of problems in the cold as it can threaten the life of your engine or generator, but it won’t usually freeze up and fail on you entirely which makes it quite useful.
All and all, conditions where propane and gasoline will fail on you in the winter is extremely rare in the US, while the same cannot be said for uninsulated natural gas which is quite vulnerable to the cold. For this reason, it is good to not rely too heavily on natural gas in the winter months and to keep backup sources of fuel and heating available no matter where you live in the country. Hopefully this article has helped you to better understand your fuels and their limitations and how best to protect yourself and your home when Jack Frost comes knocking at the door in winters to come.